Fast Loans | Car Insurance | Mobile Phones | Advertising | MPAA
Lawyers a plague destroying our health care [Archive] - FreeConservatives

PDA

View Full Version : Lawyers a plague destroying our health care


PaulRevere
08-31-2002, 09:25 AM
Paul Greenberg (archive)

August 30, 2002

A plague spread by lawyers

It's happening all over the country. Plaintiffs' lawyers are suing and collecting. Which means insurance companies are having to pay. Which means doctors and hospitals are being charged higher and higher premiums for their malpractice insurance. Which means that, in state after state, doctors can't afford to practice and hospitals have to cut back on services. Which means people who need medical attention don't get it.

Lest you think that's an exaggeration, check out this front-page story in Sunday's New York Times:

Rise in Insurance Forces Hospitals To Shutter Wards

It's happening across the country, according to The Times:

"In the last few weeks, the only trauma center in Las Vegas closed for 10 days; the Central Florida Regional Hospital in Sanford, Fla., reduced surgical procedures for five days; and a handful of rural clinics across Mississippi sat empty in the summer heat for part of a week. All the problems were because of problems with problems with malpractice insurance. .

The complaints have grown familiar by now. They come from doctors ready to pack it in, and hospital administrators at the end of their tether. And the facts back them up. The conclusion becomes inescapable: There's a health crisis in the legal making.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~snip~~~~~~~~~~~~~

The Bush administration has tried to get Congress' attention as this medical/legal crisis developed. It suggested limiting out-of-control jury awards, but was stymied by the Democrats in the Senate.

When one party has been largely captured by a special interest -- in this case, the trial lawyers' lobby -- the chances for reform begin to resemble those of a poor patient in urban Philadelphia or rural Mississippi.

web page (http://www.townhall.com/columnists/paulgreenberg/pg20020830.shtml)

Desertrat06
08-31-2002, 09:16 PM
RANDy, the only problem with that comment is that it ain't quite true. For instance, back when Florida ran out of Ob/Gyn and had almost nothing left but mid-wives, the reason was malpractice insurance premiums of $250,000 per year--per the Tallahassee Democrat.

A doctor I knew in Thomasville, GA, commented to me that "When I hit the office on Monday morning, I'm $1,000 in the hole." Multiply that malpractice insurance premium by 52, okay?

My mother said the best doctor in Panama City, FL (she'd checked out quite a few) had a sign in his waiting room: "I Have No Malpractice Insurance." He could afford to charge less for an office visit, and thus had plenty of patients.

Regardless, with respect to the title of the thread, lawsuits could not be brought except as Congress has passed laws which allow suits to be brought. Congress has not done much to keep awards to a reasonable level, as well.

Once we got (by law) away from the concept of negligence as the necessary cause for tort action, and went to the "deep pockets" doctrine, things have pretty much headed for the toilet. Congress started this garbage around 1966.

'Rat

The_RANDy_Corporation
09-01-2002, 12:01 AM
did you know the average doctor's car payments exceeds his malpractice coverage premium payment?